• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Simply So Good

  • Home
  • About
  • Recipes
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Fresh Mozzarella – FAILED!!

Fresh Mozzarella – FAILED!!

March 3, 2014 Updated May 2, 2017 42 Comments

5 shares
  • Share
  • Tweet

I had decided years ago that someday I was going to start making fresh mozzarella.  There is nothing quite like fresh pulled mozzarella.  It is so soft and tender that it can melt in your mouth.  I had talked with people that told me it was so easy.  I had read instructions, watched YouTube demonstrations, read blog after blog. After all if you want correct information, bloggers are the perfect source…right?

I spent a day in search of the perfect ingredients.  I had purchased citric acid, rennet tablets and vegetable rennet liquid, and the freshest local whole milk I could find.  I had several recipes that I had compared and taken notes on.  I had bookmarked several different YouTube “how to” videos.

I WAS ready.  I was ready to become the next great cheesemonger.  Bring it!

I am about to share with you photos of my 5th and 6th attempt to make the perfect mozzarella.

My first attempt was probably my best.  However, the cheese had the consistency of a rubber super ball, no flavor and did not melt.   “Hmmm it must have been the microwaving of the curd”, said I.  I only assumed that 30 minutes to fresh mozzarella was a myth…a blogger lie???

My next attempt took 3 hours to get the perfect curd.  I watched with anticipation.  I was certain my second attempt was my great success.  FAIL!  After dripping the curd tied up in cheesecloth attached to a cupboard knob in my kitchen overnight, I carefully untied and unraveled the cheese cloth to see beautiful curd.  I cut the curd carefully,  Nibbled on a bit of the curd.  Needs salt.  I warmed a gallon of salty water to 170 degrees and placed my lovely curd into the water.  Right before my eyes my curd dissolved.  NOOOOOO!!

I was not going to let mozzarella beat me.  I was never going to purchase rubbery mozzarella again.

I carefully watched the temperature of my milk and citric acid with my handy instant read thermometer,  I carefully lifted the curd and ever so lovingly drained the whey.

My next two attempts…FAIL!

On my final attempt I decided to try two different recipes side-by-side.  Everything was going so well. That’s when I decided to adjust the cheese cloth a bit before tying string around the ball of curd to drain the whey while it dripped slowly into a bowl.

One corner of the cheesecloth slipped from my fingers and that’s when the disaster occurred.   Every bit of curd came gushing out of the cheesecloth. I had cheese curd mixed with whey splashing all over me and my kitchen.  Just like a big baby hurling regurgitated milk.

The explosion was a brief moment that would take me hours to clean up.

I started to laugh, but wanted to cry.  Quick grab the camera!  This is a post in the making.

I looked at my kitchen floor.  It resembled what my floor looked like when I had a baby who spit up ALL the time.  I remember walking down the halls of my church when a little boy said, “hey lady your baby just barfed”.  I turned around and sure enough all the way down the hall there were splats of baby puke that completely resembled this scene.  Not to mention that it smelled about the same.

I had curds and whey all down the front of me and on my shoes.  It was everywhere.

You know that husband of mine that rarely reads my blog?  He walked into the kitchen took a look at me and the kitchen floor and simply said, “Give it up”!

To which I shouted, “NEEEVVVAAA”!!!

All is not lost.  My kitchen floor is clean.  My cupboards are mostly clean.  I have buckets of curd.  I’m pretty sure I basically have made ricotta the HARD way.  I have GALLONS of whey.  I can hold my head high and say that I tried.

In the end I am defeated.  I give up.  As cool as this looks hanging in my kitchen I have to admit I have been beaten.  Fresh mozzarella has taken me down.  The price of fresh pulled mozzarella pales in comparison.  I’m taking a break from the cheese business.

C’est la vie.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Previous Post: « Petite Brioche with Pearl Sugar
Next Post: Meyer Lemon Madeleines »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Amanda says

    February 13, 2022 at 6:25 pm

    Sounds like your using superpasturized milk, it extends the shelf life of the milk but its not suitable for making cheese that requires a curd as the protiens are broken and wont form the proper curds…Borden brand is the only milk I have found in my area that isnt superpasturized just merely pasturized…

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      February 20, 2022 at 2:29 am

      Thank you so much for your suggestions. This makes complete sense. I’m hoping I can find just pasteurized milk.

      Reply
  2. Lee says

    September 5, 2021 at 3:27 pm

    HIhi i hv the same problem as urs is there any way to save them..?

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      September 6, 2021 at 2:55 am

      There probably is a way to save a batch but I’m not sure what that would be. All was not lost because I had some lovely ricotta. I wish you the best of luck. Please let me know if you have any other questions. xJanet

      Reply
  3. Dipti Shetye says

    July 8, 2020 at 5:15 pm

    Hi Janet, My first n second experience was same as yours… However during by second attempt when the milk did not thicken as required post adding rennet solution and keeping it covered and untouched for 3 hours.. I too was disappointed.. But i thought of heating the entire MIXTURE as it is on low flame until it reached 110 degree fahrenheit… And VOILA!! It turned out Perfect… I then instead of microwaving it gave a nice wash in kinda warm hot water bath and tighten it in ball form, dipped in ice bath for 10 mins and it was a perfect elastic soft n fresh mozarella… Since then it is the same process i have been following… I suppose it is due to the climate where i reside, i reside in india and here the temparature neva allows my curds to form well as per typical instructions instead this method works perfect

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      July 8, 2020 at 8:43 pm

      BRAVO!!! Maybe it’s time I try again. I will definitely follow your tips and tricks. Thank you so much!!!

      Reply
      • Bill Edwards says

        December 21, 2020 at 8:29 pm

        I must be very slow for I have tried now 5 times with 1 partial success. At least it would some what melt on a pizza. Ive GONE through 4 gallons of milk in 2 days. With 0 success. I too have given up.

        Reply
        • Janet Barton says

          December 22, 2020 at 4:30 am

          I’m sorry you didn’t have success. At least you tried! I hope to give it a try again someday, but I just hate wasting the milk.

          Reply
      • Jack Frost says

        January 3, 2021 at 4:52 am

        Cheesemaking.com is the place to go. I have made mozzerella three times and recovered the ricotta cheese from the leftover whey after making the mozzerella. Each time the process worked great and I found this article while searching for things to make with the fresh cheese. I gave my gf the cup of ricotta tonight so she can make some stuffed shells for us. I will be making some pizza to finish off the mozzerella. Good luck!

        Reply
        • Janet Barton says

          January 3, 2021 at 9:32 pm

          Thank you so much for the link. I will definitely read ALL the information. Thanks for giving me hope.

          Reply
  4. dori says

    September 10, 2018 at 4:57 pm

    I have failed!!!!! tried twice. Got great ricotta cheese though. i really don’t know where i went wrong!! i do feel your pain.

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      September 11, 2018 at 5:29 pm

      Oh no! Yes, ricotta is the perk from a fail. If at first…quit! Someday I’ll try again.

      Reply
  5. BILLYBOBS says

    August 24, 2018 at 10:48 pm

    i ALSO HAVE HAD 2 FAILURES WHICH RESULTED IN GREAT RICOTTA. eXCEPTIONALLY FRUSTRATING… 25 OR 30 YEARS AGO i TRIED TO MAKE YORKSHIRE PUDDING AND FOR SOME UNKNOWN REASON IT FAILED. i TRIED AGAIN 2 OR 3 YEARS LATER AND HAVE NEVER HAD A PROBLEM AGAIN… MY YORKSHIRE PUDDING IS wORLD FAMOUS… 😉
    bUT THE MOZZARELLA… i HAVE NO IDEA WHAT i HAVE DONE WRONG. RAW MILK IS NOT AVAILABLE IN CANADA SO THAT IS NOT AN OPTION. THE CLOSEST US STATE IS MONTANA WHERE RAW MILK IS ALSO NOT LEGAL… PART OF ME WANTS TO CONTINUE TRYING THE OTHER PART SAYS JUST BUY THE STUFF…
    GREAT RICOTTA…

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      August 25, 2018 at 7:07 pm

      Ha ha I’m so sorry. You are much more ambitious than I am. Great ricotta is definitely a perk. Now Yorkshire pudding I CAN make. I have researched how to make fresh mozz and have no idea where I went wrong. If at first you don’t succeed,……

      Reply
  6. J walton says

    February 6, 2018 at 8:58 pm

    I just tried to make it all was fine till I tried to kneed it ,it’s like scrambled egg I put it back in the hot liquid but to no avail ,what did I do wrong at the end ,

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      February 8, 2018 at 7:48 pm

      I wish I knew. It’s a conundrum for sure. I was able to knead the cheese just once, but it was similar to rubber. I’m sorry I’m not much help. I have decided to purchase fresh mozz from a local grocer.

      Reply
  7. Unknown says

    March 4, 2017 at 4:02 am

    I am also having big trouble. I get to the part where you add the rennet and all I get is what looks like scrambled eggs sunk in whey. Do you know if that stuff is edible, or have you always tossed it?

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      March 7, 2017 at 10:58 pm

      I'm obviously NOT an expert, but is that the curd that is kneaded to turn into cheese? Maybe that's what is all over my kitchen floor 🙂

      Reply
  8. FreedomofNOW says

    January 10, 2016 at 12:11 pm

    I too have been defeated 3 times in a row now. I get beautiful curds (now, not the first time but that was because of the milk being homogenized) but it doesn't turn elastic as it should when it is under heat. I refuse to be beaten, though! I will learn the art of mozzarella! The magic will be mine!

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      January 10, 2016 at 3:56 pm

      Way to go. I admire your ambition. Please pass on any secrets or tips you discover. I'm ashamed to say the mozzarella whooped me.

      Reply
  9. Eddi Marks says

    March 16, 2014 at 2:45 am

    Janet- My beautiful sister in Colorado taught me how to make mozzarella. It is a bit tricky but can be done with fabulous success. I think it's much easier to make with a friend. If you are ever in Texas or Southern Colorado come by and either I or my sister will make some with you. It is sooooooooooo good. And, yes the ricotta you make from the way is just as good. A bit time consuming but oh so worth the work!

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      March 16, 2014 at 4:39 am

      This is what I needed to hear. I was thinking it wasn't worth the time. I go to Denver to visit my daughter, but not southern Colorado. Now I'm sad. I would LOVE to watch you make mozzarella. You have given me hope.

      Reply
  10. Le Coin de Mel says

    March 4, 2014 at 5:44 pm

    Oh my goodness, you are one determined lady, Janet! Your text and photos made me laugh, but I know I should not. It is not funny when you try and try and try again and feel like you have been lied to… I will never attempt making mozzarella myself (not that I'd even considered it). x Mel

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      March 5, 2014 at 10:51 pm

      You can laugh. I did. I had to so I wouldn't cry. Ha ha. I'll probably try again….

      Reply
  11. lynda thompson says

    March 4, 2014 at 5:38 pm

    You can make mozzarella, and then ricotta from the leftover liquid, rather easily without all the work. I'm not sure what went wrong for you. I have to admit it is nice to see that someone has posted real photos of proof that they have had such messes from trying to do things. I seem to get things done, but I drop stuff etc.

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      March 5, 2014 at 10:52 pm

      Ahhh where did I go wrong? This isn't the only mess I have had. I figure it out eventually. Thanks for your comment.

      Reply
  12. April says

    March 4, 2014 at 2:30 pm

    You are a tougher woman than I! I would have quit after 3, probably bawling my eyes out. I think I take this cooking thing a little too seriously sometimes… I have a tendency to throw tantrums at failure… Ah well. Thanks for sharing your journey. It was fun 🙂

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      March 5, 2014 at 10:54 pm

      I have a problem that I can't sleep until I can figure out what I did wrong. I went through 6 lbs of butter trying to figure out English Toffee. I figured out the problem and haven't had trouble since. Hmmm I'm stumped on this cheese. Thanks for your comment.

      Reply
  13. Stephanie Adderley says

    March 4, 2014 at 1:45 pm

    I've tried making moz before – and failed. I even have the fancy etsy cheese making kit. First attempt I at least got some good ricotta out of it. Second attempt was a complete fail. I think my problem is I can't get the separation of curds and whey during heating properly. I don't know if it is the electric cook top or what….
    Also attempted a few times with goats milk (for goats cheese). Again first one okay second attempt no separation…
    My FH also told me to take a break lol.

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      March 5, 2014 at 10:54 pm

      So what are we doing wrong??? Someone will help us. Thanks for making me not feel so alone.

      Reply
  14. Candace says

    March 3, 2014 at 11:49 pm

    I'm laughing, but I feel your pain, Janet! Seems I saw someone on the Food Network do this – Bobbie Flay, Tyler Lawrence, Giada? How is it they make it look SO easy! I admire your stick-to-it-ness, but sometimes you just know when enough is enough (wink). On the brighter side – everything else you show us how to cook always works well the first time!
    Cheers!

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      March 5, 2014 at 10:55 pm

      Thanks for your confidence. I'm trying not to loose sleep over it. Ugh!

      Reply
  15. Marilyn Broadbent Oveson says

    March 3, 2014 at 10:27 pm

    Oh Janet! This post is so funny and so sad! I'm so sorry you failed in your cheese making attempts, on the other hand, I'm relieved to learn that you are human (not flawed on my scale, but nevertheless…). Thanks for sharing your failure, I need to be reminded that it's ok.

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      March 3, 2014 at 11:04 pm

      I look at it this way… I'm here to fail for you 🙂

      Reply
  16. Daniela says

    March 3, 2014 at 9:15 pm

    Oh, wow! I just get back from a few weeks off the internet, I get to your blog to see what is up, and… you are making cheese! Even if you still don't get it right, it's really cool!

    I've made cheese weekly during a whole year back in high school, would you post the steps that you follow so far? maybe I can help you find the problem?

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      March 3, 2014 at 11:08 pm

      I was hoping someone out there would say "let me help you". I didn't take photo's of the steps I took. I will probably try again because it's making me crazy. I'm thinking it could be my milk. I'm using the freshest local milk I can find, but it is pasteurized. Does my milk need to be "raw" with the cream on top without pasteurization? One recipe called for buttermilk as well as citric acid. I wonder if that's a problem?

      Reply
    • Daniela says

      March 4, 2014 at 2:06 pm

      Pasteurization is not really an issue, plenty of cheeses are made from pasteurized milk. So, don't worry about it.

      There is two ways of making mozzarella, one is with the use of some acid to drop the pH of the milk before the adition of the rennet. The other, and my personal favourite, is by adding lactic cultures and let them transform the sugars into acids (lactic and citric mostly), to drop the pH. I find this reaction more flexible and easier to control, since you want a just slightly acidic milk before the rennet.

      Well, from what I can see in the photos, the curd looks like ricotta, and it shouldn't. That happens when there is too much acid in the mix and the casein precipitates (separates from the rest of the milk) before the enzimes of the rennet can actually work. You're aiming for a "chunks of panna cotta in whey" look.

      Try this method by making a pilot batch: mix a cup of warm whole milk (or half and half if its from the store) with one or two tablespoons of plain yogurt, let it rest at 100 ºF just until you see the milk starting to change its density. Then add the rennet, following the manufacturer instructions. Also add a little pinch of salt (this is going to help to separate the fat, the sugars and the proteins from the water), mix as little as you can, and let it rest for one hour at, again, 100 ºF. After that time, the curd should look like a flan floating at the top of the liquid, and should be apart from the sides of the pot. Cut the curd with a knife, it should be a clean cut, with sharp edges. If it's not, maybe the issue is with the rennet.

      If it is a nice looking curd, try making a bigger batch, then cut the curd in cubes, drain it, squish it up, put it in hot salted water and knead it. Don't overwork it (that's why that one batch was like rubber) and inmediately put the mozzarella in icy water until is cooled off.

      Reply
    • Daniela says

      March 4, 2014 at 3:37 pm

      Both of these videos show how important it is to use cultures http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jMAlToEYHJM; http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8G6yzLSByHQ

      The texture and the aroma of the cheese will depend of the kind of feeding of the cows and the type of culture that you use. The time of the year will affect it too, because the cows have a different diet and because the bacteria in the summer air are different that the ones in the winter air. How amazing is that?? I know, I know, nerd chemist alert; but fermentation processes will always be my true love, and I miss cheese making so much!

      Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      March 5, 2014 at 10:59 pm

      I LOVE you. I was hoping someone would come forward and take my hand and walk me through the process. Dang. Now I have to try it again. I will watch the videos. Thank you so much. I'm leaving town to visit my son for a few days. I'll be back next week and try again! I'll report what happens. You're the best. So glad your back on the "net". You just might save my sanity.

      Reply
    • Daniela says

      March 6, 2014 at 2:10 pm

      If you need further info, send me an e-mail (it's in my profile), I will be very happy to help you.
      Have a lovely trip!

      Reply
  17. Milk and Honey says

    March 3, 2014 at 9:11 pm

    I've made ricotta (the easy way), but haven't tried to make mozzarella. My babies didn't have much reflux, but those photos of curdled milk all over your kitchen brought back some messy memories. You should be commended for trying so many times (I think I would have given up after the second attempt), and for writing an honest piece about the process. On reading it, I think I'll continue to get my mozzarella from the local Italian deli.

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      March 3, 2014 at 11:05 pm

      I only wish I had an Italian deli close by let alone one in my STATE! Lucky you. Thanks for your comment.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

About Me

Janet Barton

Hi I'm Janet and this is where I share my delicious made-from-scratch seasonal recipes that I make at home for my family every day.

I believe cooking from scratch, using unprocessed and whole foods is an important part of healthy eating. My goal is to help you create amazing recipes by providing easy step-by-step photos and instructions.

Read More »

Trending Recipes

  • No-knead Crusty Bread in a Dutch oven No-knead Crusty Bread
  • pink iced heart sugar cookies Sour Cream Sugar Cookies
  • Lemonade and raspberry lemonade in tall glasses Old Fashioned Lemonade
  • Kalamata olive fouggase on marble with dipping sauce Kalamata Olive and Rosemary Fougasse with Fresh Herb and Pepper Dipping Oil
  • Glass of almond milk with 2 gray striped straws on wood board with container of almond milk in background Quick Homemade Almond Milk
  • Tree cut out sugar cookies with green icing and golden sprinkles Butter Dream Sugar Cookies
  • Bunny butter cookies in a bowl with colored sprinkles Miffy Petit Beurre (Shortbread Cookies)
  • overhead shot of no-knead Dakota Bread on a blue cloth No-Knead Dakota Bread
  • Homemade Buttermilk Ricotta
  • Lemon Curd Ice Cream in bread pan with spoon Lemon Curd Ice Cream

Latest on Instagram

simplysogood

It’s time for Miffy cookies! I love these cute l It’s time for Miffy cookies! I love these cute little French shortbread Miffy Petit Beurre cookie. These cute little butter shortbread cookies melt in your mouth. 🐰💗

You don’t need a Miffy cookie cutter in order to make this delicious shortbread cookie. You can make them any shape.

#easter #bunny #shortbread
My favorite chocolate cupcakes topped with the flu My favorite chocolate cupcakes topped with the fluffiest white chocolate icing. 

This is an old vintage recipe from my childhood and is called “Ermine frosting”. It is so smooth and creamy. It’s definitely not your normal icing. It is less sweet and super fluffy. I think you’ll love it❣️

The recipe is linked in my bio. 😘

#valentinesday #feb14 #valentine
Oh baby! This combination: Chocolate, Banana, and Oh baby!  This combination: Chocolate, Banana, and Nutella🔥The most extremely moist chocolate banana cupcakes, with Nutella icing… Plus a little surprise of chocolate chunks inside!

The Nutella icing is so creamy and delicious.  It’s loaded with Nutella and a bit of sour cream. 🤤 

#chocolatebanana #chocolatecupcakes #nutellabanana
Valentine’s Day = Sugar Cookies! Am I the only Valentine’s Day = Sugar Cookies!

Am I the only one who craves sugar cookies beginning February 1st?  It’s time to stock up on butter & Valentine sprinkles. 💗

You can find my favorite Valentines sugar cookie recipes in the link in my bio. They are all so buttery 🤤 and will melt-in-your-mouth and freeze great. 

Baking starts now!! 

#valentinescookies #sugarcookies #thebestsugarcookies #valentines
The lunar new year is soon approaching this Sunday The lunar new year is soon approaching this Sunday, January 22. We are celebrating the year of the rabbit with these homemade Mandarin Pork Potstickers with Ginger Soy Sauce for dipping!!

Wishing you a fabulous year filled with love, peace, bunny ears, and potstickers. ✌️❤️🐰 🥟

#lunarnewyear #potstickers #yearoftherabbit
Why I love slow cooker lentil soup: * I can throw Why I love slow cooker lentil soup:

* I can throw the ingredients into a slow cooker before I go to bed and it will be hot and steamy when I finish a long, cold run in the morning.
* I can toss the ingredients into a slow cooker in the morning and let it do its magic all day for a quick supper. 
* It’s brothy!  I love brothy soups. 
* It’s noted with healthy and nutritious ingredients.
* This recipe can be made in an instant pot in about 20 minutes!
Recipe link in bio

#lentilsoup #crockpotsoup #slowcookersoup
This is a very quick version of Christmas Stollen This is a very quick version of Christmas Stollen flavored bread. The sweet dough is filled with dried fruit, candied orange and lemon peel, and almonds. 

The dough is wrapped around a ribbon of marzipan filling. Bake until golden then dust heavily with powder sugar. 

I like to toast a thick slice then scoop out the warm marzipan and spread it all over my toasted Stollen 🤤

#christmasbaking #stollenbread
#christmasrecipe
Biscotti literally means “twice baked”, and do Biscotti literally means “twice baked”, and double baking is the secret to these crunchy Italian cookies. Their hard texture makes them perfect for dipping into your hot drink. 

Chocolate Hazelnut Biscotti are my favorite and I add them to my Christmas cookie list because they make such a cute gift, but most of all I love dipping them in my cocoa. 

#biscotti #christmascookies #christmasbaking
During my September runs I start looking for the p During my September runs I start looking for the perfect juniper bush for my natural gingerbread houses. 
The bushes must be filled with perfect purple berries. 

In December in start snipping those twigs and berries to adorn my natural little houses. I add nuts, cinnamon sticks, whole cloves, herbs, and a dusting of powdered sugar. ☺️

#gingerbreadhouse #gingerbread
#nature
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Footer

Featured on

The Daily Meal Logo The foodgawker-logo reddit Logo BuzzFeed Logo halfbaked Harvest Logo Browneyed Baker Logo FOOD52 Logo University of Washington Logo sheknows Logo

Copyright © 2023 Janet Barton
Privacy Policy