• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Simply So Good

  • Home
  • About
  • Recipes
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Recipes / Breads and Rolls / Crusty “No-Knead” Bread Forum

Crusty “No-Knead” Bread Forum

August 31, 2012 Updated May 23, 2018 702 Comments

24shares
  • Share
  • Tweet

 

I realize that asking a question and trying to get or even FIND the answer is getting a bit ridiculous on the Crusty Bread page.  This is by far the most popular post I have with over 1.2 MILLION page views.  Who knew????  Oh my gosh.  I knew the first time that I made this bread that I had to share it with the world.  It’s so easy, yet so delicious and has SO many possibilities.  Here is your turn to share, ask, comment, complain,  or rave about your bread success. 

 I will first begin with the most frequently asked questions.  After that I would love for you to share your amazing bread creations.  I just can’t believe some of the combinations that have been shared so far.  What fabulous cooks you are.
I hope this works and makes it easier for you to view comments and ask questions and get responses.
If you haven’t heard of the “No-Knead” bread that produces easy artisan bread, here is the link:  https://www.simplysogood.com/crusty-bread/
 I must begin by saying where the recipe originated if in fact, it originated anywhere…really.  I think bread has been baked for centuries using flour, salt, water, and yeast or another form of leavening.  As far as I know, the recipe for “No-Knead” bread dough was printed in the New York Times.  I don’t know what month, day, or year.  The originator is Jim Lahey of Sullivan Street Bakery.  That’s all I know.  I found the recipe in a booklet using enamel cast iron pots.  At the time I posted the recipe I had no Jim Lahey even existed or I would have definitely given the man full credit for this wonderful bread and idea.  That said….
Remember before beginning to create that this bread is highly forgiving.  Don’t stress over the fact that you haven’t proofed the yeast or that you’re not giving the dough a second rising time.  It’s super duper sticky and will stick to your hands, feet, and hair or anything else it comes in contact with.  Play with the recipe for your location.  Altitudes differ and that can affect the bread.  This recipe is not your ordinary bread recipe.  Just chill and follow the instructions.  There are some fabulous comments and suggestions.  Hopefully, you can find answers to questions a bit easier now.  
Breath.
 FAQ’s

Q:  Do I have to use an enamel covered cast iron pan?

A:  NO.  You can use anything that can take the heat.  The following have been used that I know of:
Clay pots with lids, Pizza stone with a bowl to cover the bread, insert from a crockpot, pyrex baking dish with a lid, stainless steel pot with a lid, baking dish covered with aluminum foil, old cast iron dutch oven.

Q:  Do I have to use unbleached flour?

A:  I always use unbleached flour.  You can try bleached flour.

Q:  Can I use self rising flour?

A:  I don’t know.  I would just stick to all-purpose.

Q:  What size is my pan?

A:  My smallest pan is 5.5 quart and the loaf barely fits.

Q:  What type of yeast do I use?

A:  I use SAF instant yeast.  Any yeast should work.

Q:  Why is my bread turning out flat?

A:  I don’t know.  You could try using less 1/4 cup less liquid.  Or add a bit more flour.  Make sure your dough appears to be dry when you first mix it.  It will have more moisture during the rising time. There are many determining factors when bread making.  Is your flour old?  It does make a difference.  Sometimes store brand, sale flour isn’t so great and should probably be left on the store shelf.  Make sure your flour is fresh and a good quality brand and make sure your yeast is fresh and active.

Q:  Can my dough sit out longer than 18 hours?  Does it HAVE to be between 12-18 hours?

A:  No. I have let some dough sit as long as 24 hours and the bread was beautiful.

Q:  Have you tried Gluten-free?

A:  No.  I’m still waiting for someone to venture into the realm of Gluten-free. If you try it, let everyone know.

Q:  Do I have to grease or oil the pan?  Will my bread stick?

A:  No you don’t need to grease the pan.  I have never had the bread stick when using a cast iron pot.  I haven’t tried anything else.  The best way to be certain that the bread won’t stick is to form the loaf on a sheet of parchment paper and lift the bread into the pan using the sides of the parchment.  Leave the paper in the pan.  It’s won’t burn.  When the bread has baked, just lift the sides of the parchment out of the pan.  Voila!

Q:  What temperature should my water be?

A:  I just use cool water straight from the tap.

Q:  Can I add sugar?

A:  Sure.

What is the difference between active dry yeast and instant yeast (also known as bread machine yeast)?
Instant yeast is a little more potent than active dry yeast and can be mixed in with your dry ingredients directly. I generally find it easier to work with. Active dry yeast works just as well as instant yeast but requires being activated in a little bit of warm water before being added to the rest of the ingredients. Failure to properly activate it will result in your loaf not rising adequately.    http://www.thefreshloaf.com/faqs/baking/yeast

My most recipe comment that will be so helpful to all of you.  Thank you so much, Cory – Falling Star Lane:

Hi! Me again! I have some input – mostly add in ideas that have been huge hits! I found that using the parchment makes all the difference – to any loaf, it makes it easy to put in and take out and never burns.
Also, I reduced the baking time by 5 minutes for each step – more tender bred, and just as crispy crust.
I also add 1 T of raw sugar to each loaf – they rise higher for me.

As to add ins –

1. Turkey bacon and cheddar – huge hit
2. Rosemary, feta and sundried tomatoes – i found the ones in oil to bring a fantastic flavor
3. Jalapeno, and pepper jack – wow!!! used canned peppers – small can
4. Chocolate and cranberry
5. Rosemary and sharp cheddar
6. Chocolate chip and orange infused cranberries
7. Apricot, cranberry, and chocolate – I put too much in – so i had very dense bread – but it got eaten!!
8. Rosemary and Feta
9. Marinated artichokes and raw garlic – sliced 6 cloves very thinly – oh boy!
10. Orange infused cranberry, almond and orange zest
11. Lemon zest, feta, and rosemary

S0 far, none have been rejected, and I have become something of a bread baker to my friends – I bring a couple varieties to potluck, and they are very nicely received! I still need a 2nd dutch oven – days i bake 3-5 loaves it gets pretty hot around here! 🙂

I hope listing these is ok – i spent soooo long scrolling thru to see other peoples ideas, it seemed like this would be a good thing – found a few to try, and in fact making a pistachio and cranberry tonite, and an olive mozerella – new is good – but i get asked for the Jalapeno one most often!!

Thanks again for this blog post!

Most of the comments I receive are pretty fabulous like this comment.  Keep them coming.

Thanks, to Sarah for submitting photo’s of her cranberry/pistachio and jalapeno /cheddar  loaves.  Don’t they look amazing?

 

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Breads and Rolls

Previous Post: « Herb Butter
Next Post: Summer Garden Pasta »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Rob says

    August 12, 2020 at 12:40 am

    Hi,
    I’ve made no knead bread a few times with great success.
    I was thinking of using a Sourdough starter. What do you think the ratios of water to starter would be.
    Thanks Rob

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      August 19, 2020 at 10:36 pm

      I have not yet perfected a sourdough loaf of the no-knead bread. NYT suggests 3/4 cup fed sourdough starter mixed with 1 1/4 cup lukewarm water. I’ll try more sourdough options once the weather cools down. It’s been SO hot in my neck of the woods.

      Reply
      • Rob says

        August 20, 2020 at 2:29 am

        Thanks Janet, I will give the proper sourdough a try when I have a couple of spare days

        Reply
        • Janet Barton says

          August 24, 2020 at 3:33 am

          Please let us know the results of your sourdough crusty bread.

          Reply
          • Rob says

            August 24, 2020 at 3:36 am

            👌

  2. Laura says

    January 16, 2019 at 7:20 pm

    WhaT if i don’t have parchment paper?

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      January 16, 2019 at 10:38 pm

      I started out baking this bread not using parchment paper. Just drop the dough into the hot pot. I have never had the bread stick to a cast iron or enamel cast iron pot. Just carefully lift the hot bread out of the pot with hot pads. The use of parchment paper makes it easier to drop the dough into the hot pot and lift it out. No worries if you don’t have parchment paper.

      Reply
  3. Lucy Wynne, Kent ~ England says

    December 19, 2017 at 9:50 pm

    Wanted to try something different for Christmas, so using basic recipe quartered I made this using mincemeat (as in mince pies) with chopped basil.
    second trial, 1/4 basic recipe, sultanas and chopped apricot soaked overnight in apple juice then drained, chopped dates, toasted almond slivers, pistachio nuts
    third trial also using quarter of basic recipe was smoked salmon trimmings, lemon zest and sugar snap peas. Brushed egg wash over when lid came off and ground pink Himalayan rock salt and black pepper over
    Fourth trial, 1/4 basic recipe smoked salmon trimmings, lemon zest, finely chopped fennel. Egg wash and salt/pepper as previously.
    All were gorgeous and will make lovely gifts. Many years ago before illness made it impossible I used to make “allday breakfast rolls” I tried these with the basic recipe and add ins of mushrooms, tomatoes, sausage, bacon lardons and egg all coarsely chopped. With the addition of unsalted butter while still warm and a mug of herbal tea. Ambrosia

    Reply
    • Janet Barton says

      December 20, 2017 at 3:50 pm

      Wow Lucy! You are brilliant! Amazing breads are coming out of your kitchen. I love your creations.

      Reply
  4. http://bigessaywriter.com/blog/a-raisin-in-the-sun-essay-what-to-include says

    April 3, 2017 at 1:48 pm

    thanks for this recipe of the best bread ever! I will cook it and shre my results!

    Reply
  5. Rachel Lau says

    February 22, 2017 at 6:17 am

    I had made this recipe hundred of times in Canada and never had any problem. However, recently I have moved to New Zealand but have problems with the yeast and/or flour, the dough just won't rise properly. Has anyone from New Zealand tried this recipe? Is yeast or flour in New Zealand much different from Canada/US? I even tried both instant yeast and active dried yeast, double the amount of yeast, the dough is still half the height it normally is. The bread ends up looking like focaccia!

    Reply
  6. Unknown says

    February 13, 2017 at 6:48 pm

    This was so easy and so delicious! Thank you for sharing! I added Parmesan, fresh basil and minced garlic that came packed in oil. AMAZING!

    Reply
  7. Quilted Rosie says

    February 4, 2017 at 5:30 pm

    Use sourdough start every time with perfect results. Substitute 1/2 cup of start for the yeast, and reduce the water by 1/4 cup.

    Reply
  8. A Daughter of Mary says

    January 25, 2017 at 1:43 pm

    Here it is January 25, 2017 and this bread is still being baked, and this wonderful site is still popular. Thanks for the video, it is extremely helpful. I started the rise in the kitchen but was afraid it was going too fast so transferred to the fridge after a few hours – total time in fridge is 18 hours. I'm happy to say things look just like the vid! Just going into the oven now and I know it will be great. Thanks again.

    Reply
  9. Bohling says

    November 24, 2016 at 5:46 pm

    I have tried this recipe, and variations of it. But, my crust comes out like a stale potato chip. Not really crispy, not really soft. Quite chewy with some crunch. Rubbery would by the word. The crumb is actually wet-ish with an odd texture that, like the crust, tends to stick to my teeth. The flavor of the bread and crust is just awesome! But, the texture is a put-off. Any hints?

    Reply
  10. Unknown says

    October 21, 2016 at 12:23 pm

    wondering if anyone has tried to make this bread and added chopped up pepperoni and shredded mozz – for a modified pepperoni bread…seems like it should work…

    I made one with olive oil and a bunch of italian seasoning – came out great and smelled awesome.

    Reply
  11. AGS says

    June 24, 2016 at 9:49 am

    Hi Janet,

    Followed your recipe except that I added 1 Tablespoon sugar. I let it sit for 11 hours. It looked exactly like your pictures both before baking and also while cooling on the counter. But I knew something was wrong because the smell while baking felt a bit off. When I tasted the bread it was slightly chewy and sour as well. Looked like it was over yeasted – could that be the case? Any advice would be appreciated because so many users have had so much praise and success – I want to be part of it!

    Thanks a lot

    Reply
  12. Unknown says

    April 22, 2016 at 3:43 am

    We like a little sweeter bread. Is it ok to add sugar or honey to the basic recipe?

    Reply
  13. Leslie Huskey says

    March 18, 2016 at 5:42 pm

    Have you ever tried making it in small loafs for soup bowls?

    Reply
  14. Anonymous says

    March 9, 2016 at 5:07 pm

    Has anyone tried a rye flour recipe? I had seen one for whole wheat where you use 2 3/4 cup of whole wheat flour and 2 cups of water. The bread turned out wonderful. Wondering if this ratio would work for rye bread as well?

    Reply
  15. Anonymous says

    March 1, 2016 at 4:06 am

    You should definitely check out Jim Lahey's cook book. I got it about 6 years ago and LOVE it. I first found this recipe in Mark Bittman's How to Cook Everything Book and that's where I learned about the magic of Jim Laheys methods. This bread is absolutely scrumptious.

    Reply
  16. Janet Barton says

    March 1, 2016 at 3:33 am

    Hi Karin, I have never tried kneading in honey, but I'm sure it's delicious. This is a pretty forgiving recipe, so the addition of honey would be great. Difficult to knead in after the rise, however.

    Reply
  17. Karin says

    February 28, 2016 at 6:05 pm

    Hi there, I have a quick question. I am trying this bread today for the first time. Mine is currently covered and sitting for the next many hours!
    I read another bread recipe this morning where someone kneaded in honey, then baked the bread. Have you ever tried this, or have any suggestions as to whether this would even be a good idea? Just wondering. Thank you!
    Karin

    Reply
  18. phyllis umberger says

    February 3, 2016 at 7:34 am

    Can you use muffin tins for this bread or does it always need to be covered?

    Reply
  19. Janet Barton says

    January 28, 2016 at 10:28 pm

    I don't pack in the flour. I stir and scoop the flour before I measure. It really doesn't matter what you use to cover the dough. Just as long as the dough doesn't dry out on top.

    Reply
  20. denise - SUPERWOWOMG says

    January 28, 2016 at 6:15 am

    I've just made my first bread EVER and this makes me SO HAPPY cos i just love bread so much. It turned out a bit more dense than I had hoped for and I know it's cos I added a bit of extra water when I was mixing it with the flour cos I thought I had to really coat all the flour. I read a comment that actually when I leave the dough to raise, the dry bits of flour will just work its way in by itself so that's noted for next time!

    I do have a question about how long I can keep the bread after it's been made? I read that a lot of breads from bakeries have preservatives in them to extend the shelf life so I wanted to know how long this "all natural" bread can keep? Thanks Janet!

    Reply
  21. Anonymous says

    January 28, 2016 at 1:42 am

    Does the flour have to be packed when measuring? Also, I have a mixing bowl with an air-tight lid. Is this fine to use or should I still cover the bowl with plastic wrap overnight?

    Reply
  22. Janet Barton says

    January 25, 2016 at 11:53 pm

    Yes, you can let the dough rise longer than 24 hours. I generally use less yeast if I am planning on it. I have had times when I have been very busy and could not bake the dough for over 24 hours. The results were just as good, but perhaps a bit more yeasty in flavor.

    Reply
« Older Comments

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

About Me

Janet Barton

Hi I'm Janet and this is where I share my delicious made-from-scratch seasonal recipes that I make at home for my family every day.

I believe cooking from scratch, using unprocessed and whole foods is an important part of healthy eating. My goal is to help you create amazing recipes by providing easy step-by-step photos and instructions.

Read More »

Trending Recipes

  • No-knead Crusty Bread in a Dutch oven No-knead Crusty Bread
  • Lemonade and raspberry lemonade in tall glasses Old Fashioned Lemonade
  • Lemon Curd Ice Cream in bread pan with spoon Lemon Curd Ice Cream
  • California veggie sandwich with fresh herb mayo California Veggie Sandwich with Fresh Herb Mayo
  • Glass of almond milk with 2 gray striped straws on wood board with container of almond milk in background Quick Homemade Almond Milk
  • Cheddar Cheese Rolls arranged on a plate Cheddar Cheese Rolls
  • Several chocolate drop cookies on white background Chocolate Drop Cookies
  • vanilla and chocolate party cakes for kids Vanilla and Chocolate Party Cakes for Kids
  • Artisan No-knead Bread
  • chocolate cupcake with strawberry icing with whole strawberry on top Strawberry Swiss Meringue Buttercream

Subscribe to our email list for exclusive tips and recipes

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Latest on Instagram

simplysogood

Mini Cadbury eggs are my Easter addiction so why n Mini Cadbury eggs are my Easter addiction so why not toss a handful into this amazing malted milk chocolate ice cream?🍦Heavenly milk chocolate ice cream is just six ingredients away 👉🏼 click the link in my bio!
Speaking of Orange Rolls... here is another recipe Speaking of Orange Rolls... here is another recipe you could try this Easter weekend!! 🍊These buttery gooey orange rolls are so easy to make — Just mix the dough in the evening and refrigerate overnight! The next morning roll, shape, and bake, DEVOUR!
Springtime and citrus go so well together don’t Springtime and citrus go so well together don’t you think!? 🍊 The fresh orange zest in the glaze brightens up these typical butterflake rolls — You’re going to love them! Click the link in my bio to read through these helpful tips that will make your orange-glazed butterflake rolls a melt-in-your-mouth success!
Nothing says Easter weekend more than Carrot Cake Nothing says Easter weekend more than Carrot Cake 🥕🍰 This family recipe is filled with pineapple, coconut, and walnuts making this cake incredibly moist and flavorful! I topped the cake with a honey-sweetened cream cheese icing for the win!
How cute are these little French shortbread Miffy How cute are these little French shortbread Miffy Petit Beurre cookies?🐰This simple little cookie, not too sweet not too rich, melts in your mouth — perfect for an Easter basket treat!
Try to resist slicing this delicate Easter bread b Try to resist slicing this delicate Easter bread before it has completely cooled! This no-knead brioche dough makes this chocolate and pecan swirled Easter bread so simple to make! Oh! And if by chance you have leftovers, try making Easter bread french toast!
I love creating food with seasonal foods and with I love creating food with seasonal foods and with what I can find growing in my garden and around my yard 💜This kale bowl, marinated beets, fruit, and pansies has easily become my favorite salad bowl! It’s loaded with flavors and nutrition.
It IS possible to have an extremely moist Banana N It IS possible to have an extremely moist Banana Nut Bread while using whole wheat flour! 🍞🍌 I add applesauce and avocado oil so the banana bread bakes up moist and retains the nutty flavor of whole grains!
My family’s goal for March is to get in those gr My family’s goal for March is to get in those greens!! This Quinoa Stuffed Avocado Makes a perfect lunch 🥑 The quinoa and kale stay fresh in the refrigerator for a few days, so I just make a big batch to eat from throughout the week! Just need to slice an avocado!
Load More... Follow on Instagram


Footer

Featured on

The Daily Meal Logo The foodgawker-logo reddit Logo BuzzFeed Logo halfbaked Harvest Logo Browneyed Baker Logo BLOGHER Logo FOOD52 Logo University of Washington Logo sheknows Logo

Copyright © 2021 Janet Barton
Privacy Policy